‘Fear of trolling stopping Indians from trying’: UPSC mentor sparks debate after Saurabh Dwivedi’s Kartavya Netflix debut goes viral
What began as criticism of journalist Saurabh Dwivedi’s acting debut has now turned into a wider debate on India’s growing culture of online mockery and fear of failure. Dwivedi, known for his political journalism and digital interviews, recently appeared in Netflix’s crime thriller Kartavya, which premiered on May 15 alongside actor Saif Ali Khan. While the film generated attention for its storyline and ensemble cast, social media quickly shifted focus to Dwivedi’s performance, with clips from the film widely shared through memes, jokes and harsh criticism.
UPSC mentor says society is discouraging failure
The backlash prompted a response from Shekhar Dutt, a UPSC mentor followed by many civil services aspirants online. In a post on X, Dutt argued that constantly mocking people for trying something new discourages experimentation and increases fear of failure. He said Indians should feel comfortable exploring different paths without worrying that one unsuccessful attempt could instantly become viral content.
— DuttShekhar (@DuttShekhar)
Dutt’s remarks quickly resonated with many social media users who believe internet culture has become increasingly unforgiving. Several people supported the idea that public humiliation now arrives faster than constructive criticism, especially for those stepping outside their comfort zones.
Fear of public ridicule shaping choices
The conversation soon expanded beyond films and acting. In today’s digital environment, even ordinary attempts at creativity or self-expression can attract ridicule online. From aspiring singers and content creators to entrepreneurs and professionals changing careers, many people now hesitate before taking risks publicly.
He said that this growing fear of judgment is contributing to a larger culture of risk-aversion among young Indians. Starting a business, changing professions, or pursuing unconventional goals often involves uncertainty. But when failures are mocked more loudly than efforts are appreciated, many choose safer and more predictable paths instead.
Netizens say public figures must face scrutiny
Not everyone agrees with the sympathetic view towards Dwivedi. Some argued that acting is a serious profession requiring preparation and skill, particularly in a major Netflix production. Since viewers invest time and money into entertainment, they believe audiences have every right to openly criticise performances they find weak or unconvincing.Others also pointed out that Dwivedi himself built a career around analysing and commenting on public figures. For some online users, the backlash simply reflects the nature of public life and criticism in the digital age.
Film gains attention amid controversy
Directed by Pulkit and produced by Red Chillies Entertainment, Kartavya explores themes of morality, duty and social pressure in small-town India. While reviews for the project have been mixed to positive, the controversy surrounding Dwivedi’s performance has significantly increased public curiosity around the film.
Bigger debate about modern internet culture
The episode reflects a broader contradiction in modern online culture. Society often praises stories of resilience and comeback success, whether in sports, business or entertainment. Yet social media platforms frequently reward instant judgment and sarcasm far more than patience or balanced discussion.
Supporters of Dutt’s argument say encouraging people to try new things does not mean lowering standards or avoiding honest criticism. Constructive feedback remains important. However, they warn that turning every failed attempt into nationwide mockery could eventually create a generation too afraid to take risks publicly.
As discussions around Kartavya continue, the controversy has evolved into something larger than one acting performance. It has opened up questions about how India reacts to failure, experimentation and vulnerability in an age where every mistake can become viral entertainment overnight.
